09 May Learning From Past Submissions: How To Turn Client Feedback Into Stronger Bids

One of the most valuable yet often underutilised resources in bid writing is buyer feedback from past submissions. Whether a bid was successful or not, the insights provided by evaluators can be transformative, because by systematically collecting, analysing, and acting on this feedback, businesses can refine their approach, enhance bid quality, and increase their win rates.

In this article, we will explore the importance of leveraging client feedback, present strategies for incorporating it into future bids, and outline how identifying recurring patterns can ensure long-term success.

The Value Of Collecting And Analysing Client Feedback

Client feedback is a goldmine of information, offering direct insight into what evaluators liked, disliked, or found lacking in a bid. But many organisations make the mistake of moving straight to the next opportunity without reflecting on past submissions, missing a critical opportunity for growth.

This is a major error, as analysing client feedback helps you do the following:

Identify Strengths And Weaknesses: Understanding what worked well allows you to reinforce those elements in future bids. Conversely, recognising weaknesses helps you address gaps before they cost you another opportunity.

Understand Client Priorities: Feedback often reveals what the client truly values, whether it’s pricing, innovation, compliance, or risk management. This knowledge sharpens your ability to tailor future bids more precisely.

Improve Consistency: By tracking feedback across multiple bids, you can spot recurring issues – such as unclear methodology or insufficient evidence – and implement systemic improvements. Without this analysis, businesses risk repeating the same mistakes, leading to stagnant success rates.

Strategies For Incorporating Constructive Feedback

Once buyer responses are collected, the next step is applying them effectively. Here’s how to ensure your business incorporates constructive feedback into your long-term development goals.

Categorise Feedback For Actionable Insights

Not all feedback is equal. Some comments may relate to pricing, others to technical solutions or presentation style. Grouping feedback into categories (e.g., compliance, value proposition, formatting) makes it easier to identify which areas need refinement.

For example, if multiple clients highlight that your risk management section was vague, you should develop a stronger, more detailed approach for future bids.

Update Bid Templates And Content Libraries

Client feedback should directly influence your bid toolkit. For instance, if evaluators frequently mention that your case studies lack impact, update them to be more results-driven. Or if pricing transparency is a recurring issue, ensure future bids include clearer cost breakdowns.

By embedding these improvements into templates, you ensure consistency and reduce the risk of past mistakes resurfacing.

Train Your Bid Team On Common Pitfalls

If feedback reveals that certain weaknesses – such as overly technical language or insufficient differentiators – persist, conduct training sessions to address them. Role-playing evaluator critiques can help bid writers anticipate client expectations and adjust their approach.

Test Revisions In Smaller Bids First

Before applying major changes to high-value bids, test your revised content in smaller or less critical submissions. This allows you to gauge whether the adjustments resonate with clients without risking a key opportunity.

Identifying Patterns To Refine Your Approach

Over time, feedback trends become apparent, and recognising these patterns is crucial for long-term improvement. 

Some Common Feedback Patterns And How To Address Them

‘Lacked innovation’ – Integrate more creative solutions into your bids, while benchmarking against industry leaders.

‘Pricing was unclear’ – Use visual aids like tables or infographics to break down costs.

‘Weak evidence of capability’ – Strengthen case studies with quantifiable results and client testimonials.

Tracking these trends in a feedback log allows for data-driven decisions. For example, if multiple clients mention that your bids are too lengthy, you might adopt a more concise writing style or use appendices for supplementary details.

The Best Practices For Requesting Detailed Feedback

Many buyers provide only generic responses (e.g. ‘another bidder scored higher’) by way of feedback. To gain actionable insights, you must proactively seek more detailed input.

Here are some ways to do this:

Ask Specific Questions

Instead of broad ‘Why did we lose?’ type queries, ask buyers more targeted questions such as:

– Which sections of our bid were strongest/weakest?

– Were there any compliance gaps?

– How could we have improved our value proposition?

Request Debrief Meetings

A phone call or face-to-face meeting often yields deeper insights than written feedback. Politely ask for a 15-minute debrief to discuss the evaluation.

Express Gratitude And Maintain Relationships

Even if the bid was unsuccessful, thank the client for their time. A professional, gracious approach keeps doors open for future opportunities.

Turn Feedback Into Future Wins

Client feedback is not just a post-bid formality – it’s a strategic tool for ensuring sustainable development. By systematically collecting, analysing, and acting on this information, businesses can refine their bidding process, avoid repetitive mistakes, and enhance their competitiveness.

The key steps include:

• Collecting feedback consistently, even after wins.
• Categorising and analysing comments to identify trends.
• Embedding improvements into templates and training.
• Proactively seeking detailed insights from clients.

By treating every piece of feedback as a stepping stone, your bids should continually improve – leading to stronger proposals and higher win rates for the foreseeable future.

Want our experts to help you win more work through better bid writing? Get in touch!